Shared Link | Friday, November 8, 2019

When Theme and Mechanics Collide

When Theme and Mechanics Collide

Examining the disconnect between mechanics and theme in games like Overland and The Banner Saga

Site iconwww.gamasutra.com

This blog post by James Margaris is kind of two articles in one, but I like them both. First, he looks at the value of alignment between a game’s mechanics (what you do and how it works) and its theming (how things are presented and framed) - mechanics are much easier to grasp intuitively if they match the theming. Next, he explains how most discussion about ludonarrative dissonance is not framed usefully and that the real problem people are pointing to is usually one of tonal dissonance that is more about the narrative than the ludo.

Tags: Shared Link, CREATOR: James Margaris, TOPIC: Storytelling

⇐ PREVIOUS LINK: Two Hat: Stop tweaking your game and start fixing your community ⇒ NEXT LINK: "Winning and measuring engagement is no longer enough"

Search Pixel Poppers

About/FAQ

First time here? Lost or confused? Got any questions? Start here!

Related Content

  • [SHARED LINK] Emotional Context In Decision Design
  • [SHARED LINK] Let's revisit Final Fantasy X ! Anyone?
  • [SHARED LINK] Good intro vs. Great intro. What makes a game prologue gripping?
  • [SHARED LINK] Sam Barlow's guide to making narrative games
  • [SHARED LINK] The Design Philosophy Of Battletech 2

Top Tags

  • Review (352)
  • Thought (310)
  • Shared Link (130)
  • TOPIC: Consumer Experience (74)
  • Article (61)
  • TOPIC: Difficulty (54)
  • Video (38)
  • TOPIC: Storytelling (33)
  • GAME: Animal Crossing: New Horizons (27)
  • TOPIC: Marketing (23)
  • TOPIC: Authorial Intent (19)
  • TOPIC: Psychology (19)
  • TOPIC: Preservation (18)
  • GAME: Dragon Quest Builders 2 (14)
  • TOPIC: Completionism (13)
  • TOPIC: Player Choice (13)
  • TOPIC: Learning (12)
  • GAME: Bubsy: Paws on Fire! (10)
  • GAME: World of Warcraft (10)
  • TOPIC: Accessibility (9)
All Tags

Newest Posts

  • [SHARED LINK] Consoles and Competition
  • [SHARED LINK] Mario but I'm Blindfolded
  • [THOUGHT] My Top Five Games of 2022
  • [REVIEW] Shadows Over Loathing
  • [REVIEW] Vampire Survivors
All Posts

© 2023 Pixel Poppers. All rights reserved. Site powered by Hugo. Comments powered by HashOver. Search powered by Lunr.